Sometimes they come back. What is “ancestral syndrome”? "Ancestor Syndrome": When your family's past harms your present

Chapter 2. Ancestor Syndrome

On June 28, 1389, the Serbs suffered a crushing defeat from the Turks on Kosovo. The Serbian prince Lazar was killed and, as is now believed, it was on this day that the decline of Greater Serbia began.

On June 28, 1914, the Serbian student Tavrilo Princip killed Archduke Ferdinand in Sarajevo, which was, if not the reason, then the reason for the outbreak of the First World War.

On June 28, 1919, the Treaty of Versailles was signed, which laid the foundation for almost all interstate problems in Europe in subsequent years and ultimately led to World War II.

On June 28, 1949, the then leader of Yugoslavia Josho Broz Tito was expelled from the Comintern and thus effectively cut off not only from influence, but also from help from the Soviet Union.

On June 28, 1989, the new Yugoslav leader Slobodan Milosevic returned the remains of St. Lazarus to Kosovo, where, as a result of this act or not, a massacre of Muslims took place, making a very negative impression on Western countries.

On June 28, 1992, François Mitterrand arrives in Kosovo to stop the bloodshed, but to no avail. After this, the West decides to begin military action against Yugoslavia, which ultimately led to the collapse of this once united state.

On June 28, 2000, Slobodan Milosevic appears before the Hague Tribunal as a war criminal.

No, all of the above is not just a coincidence. And one of the clear and vivid manifestations of the Anniversary Syndrome is one of the forms or hypostases of the so-called Ancestor Syndrome.

Anyone who wants to get acquainted with this fascinating topic, so to speak, theoretically, I strongly refer to the very popular book by Ann Anseline Schutzenberger, “The Ancestor Syndrome.” Because here I am not going to (and did not intend to) get into the jungle of this most complex phenomenon. My task is much simpler: to teach you several (more precisely, three) ways to work on yourself. Allowing you, if not to remove, then to significantly weaken the conditioning of your life by your own ancestors with all their unresolved problems, closed scenarios and other problems. That is why this chapter will be the shortest in this book. Which is quite natural, given the amount of crap that both psychogeneticists and their related family constellations have come up with in a purely methodological sense regarding psychogenetic problems! The first, for example, still spend a long time and tediously compiling all sorts of genograms, after which, having found an ancestor with similar client problems, they mostly (still!) shout joyfully: “Now do you understand? Go and do not sin! And the latter, using so-called deputies to model transgenerational problems - random people from the audience who should, as it were, play the roles of other people's relatives and ancestors - do not even suspect (or do not show that they both suspect and know...) that the result This can result in serious mental obsession, and in the case of replacing the sick or dead, illness and even untimely death!

No, with us everything is simpler and cleaner. Because when working with clients and in demonstrations at seminars, I religiously adhere to the main principle of medicine: “Do no harm!” And therefore we will do three things. Elimination of codependency on “substandard” ancestors. Cleaning up the consequences of excessive family loyalty. And the solution to the problems transmitted to you along the psychosomatic line.

By the way, about the notorious loyalty. So that, having received the results, you do not get bogged down in the swamp of pseudoscientific illusions of an occult nature, I will explain that the basis of transgenerational psychotherapy is based on a completely scientific concept invisible loyalty. By which, in this very psychogenetics, we mean the phenomenon of subordinating one’s own reactions to the environment, states, behavior patterns, beliefs and images of oneself to something that is really not too obvious. Namely, a certain social (well, of course, family) unity, expressing a kind of systemic (for the desired system) justice. As a kind of balance of accounts. We, as it were, continue the chain of generations and pay off past debts, serving the needs of a network of social and family obligations. And this is precisely what - regardless of our desire - makes us do all sorts of stupid things. Giving up his own happiness and well-being for the sake of abstract loyalty to his ancestors with all their mistakes and delusions (now considered almost as merits). Because relationships should supposedly always take into account the spirit of the law of rightness and justice within the system in which we find ourselves. And therefore, for example, in each family, along with its skeleton in the closet (or in connection with it), there is its own family ledger, which has its own debits and credits: debts, responsibilities and merits. And in any family it is possible parentification: an inversion of debts and merits, suggesting that children until the end of their lives are obliged to pay off their dads and moms, in fact becoming the parents of their parents!

From the book People Who Play Games [Book 2] by Bern Eric

THE INFLUENCE OF ANCESTORS Long before birth The origins of many life scenarios can be traced by examining the lives of the ancestors of those families who have the entire history of their ancestors traced in writing, just as is done with kings. Then you can look deeper

From the book How to Raise Parents or a New Non-Standard Child author Levi Vladimir Lvovich

Chapter 3. Day of Protection from Ancestors For adult children...taming the manipulative (manipulative mother)......how to become your mother’s dad, your grandmother’s grandfather...Do you know what the boy you asked yesterday thought why he was sad? He thought: “Yes leave me alone..." Janusz

From the book The Paradox of Passion - she loves him, but he doesn’t love her by Delis Dean K

Chapter 4. Contradiction and Commitment Syndrome (CSO) Leader in a wait-and-see position When a couple turns to me for help, during the first meeting they both say that they want to save the relationship. However, over time it becomes obvious that only the subordinate

From the book Conversations Freedom is Everything, Love is Everything Else by Bandler Richard

Chapter 25. Big Bad World. "Poor me" syndrome. She walked into my office with her head down. She was about forty and beautifully dressed. After a weak handshake, she sank weakly into a chair. I started as usual. OF: So, how can I help you? She sighed heavily. I

From the book Psychological assistance to loved ones author

Chapter 1 LOSS SYNDROME Loss syndrome (sometimes called “acute grief”) is the strong emotions experienced as a result of the loss of a loved one. The loss may be temporary (separation) or permanent (death), real or imagined, physical or

From the book Supernatural in Primitive Thinking author Lévy-Bruhl Lucien

Chapter IV. The cult of ancestors and the dead 1. The world of the dead and the world of the living Among the invisible forces, regarding which primitive man knows that he should avoid their anger and seek, if possible, favor and support, the predominant place is occupied by spirits, ancestors and

From the book 10 stupidest mistakes people make by Freeman Arthur

Chapter 2 The Chicken Little Syndrome When Chicken Little in the children's story was hit in the head with a nut, he immediately concluded that the sky was falling to the ground and ran screaming in terror. This type of behavior can be called panic dissipation. Intelligence

From the book Children and Money. What to allow, how to prohibit, what to prepare for author Demina Katerina Alexandrovna

Chapter One, which examines the complex history of three generations of our ancestors, as well as our own illusions about the finances of Our grandparents. They were born in the 30-40s of the last century, and all terrible and tragic, as well as victorious and grandiose,

From the book My Research on Genosociograms and Anniversary Syndrome author Schutzenberger Anne Anselin

Anne Anseline Schutzenberger ANCESTOR SYNDROME. Transgenerational connections, family secrets, anniversary syndrome, transmission of trauma and practical use of the genosociogram (translated from French by I.K. Masalkov) M: publishing house of the Institute of Psychotherapy, 20011 (p. 13) It is safe to say that in

From the book The Difficult Teen through the Eyes of a Sexologist [A Practical Guide for Parents] author Poleev Alexander Moiseevich

From the book Ancestor Syndrome: transgenerational connections, family secrets, anniversary syndrome, transmission of trauma and the practical use of genosociogram / Transl. I.K. Masalkov - Moscow: Publishing House of the Institute of Psychotherapy: 2001 To the therapists of the Philadelphia school, which introduced

From the book I'm not afraid of anything! [How to get rid of fears and start living freely] author Pakhomova Angelica

Chapter 5 The Romeo and Juliet Syndrome In the cases of Daniil and Kostya, the parents of the teenagers behaved almost perfectly. Unfortunately, in many cases, if not in most cases, “teenage love” the parents’ behavior leaves much to be desired: they criticize

From the book Spiral Dynamics [Managing Values, Leadership and Change in the 21st Century] by Beck Don

Chapter 1 How does the fear of God, on which the lives of our ancestors were based, differ from our everyday and social fears? Setting out on our great voyage to fearlessness, we must first of all clarify what we mean by fear, what, in fact, we want to get rid of.

From the book Extreme Situations author Malkina-Pykh Irina Germanovna

From the book What Ancestors Are Silent About author Markova Nadezhda Dmitrievna

CHAPTER 8 LOSS SYNDROME (Loss syndrome (sometimes called “acute grief”) is the strong emotions experienced as a result of the loss of a loved one. The loss can be temporary (separation) or permanent (death), real or imagined, physical or

From the book Stop Whining! Take action! author Bolotova Tatyana

Chapter 1. The Spirit of Ancestors Just as a branch cannot exist separately from a tree, so a person cannot live without the clan that gave him life. (Author unknown) Origins The family constellation method was created about thirty years ago by the German psychotherapist Bert Hellinger. With everyone

From the author's book

Call of the Ancestors One day in March, I had the opportunity to observe a flock of pigeons that settled on my balcony due to free feeding. It’s like she was spying on people! The same mating games, preening of girlfriends, inflating one’s “I” in order to avoid competition.


This book is dedicated to the work of a family therapist with family history, transgenerational connections, anniversary syndrome, and family secrets. The examples from life and history that Anna Schutzenberger gives make you think - is individual therapy really necessary? Maybe most of the problems and scenarios are brought into our lives by the family, as a system, and not by dad or mom, as individuals?
For example, a person lives and knows no grief. And at 29 years old, he breaks his spine and cannot move independently. When analyzing the genogram, it turns out that his father received exactly the same injury at this age. And if you look even further, other ancestors had the same injuries. And this is not a curse at all, but “anniversary syndrome” - but one of the key phenomena. Information about such events, as well as the “programming” of family members, is located in the collective unconscious of this family.
It is well known that it is better not to name children after relatives whose fate was tragic, since there is a possibility that the children will inherit their fate. There is a completely materialistic explanation for this: if children are named after someone, then expectations are projected onto them that they will be the same as those relatives who gave them their name.
"Nicolas Abraham (1968) tells the story of one patient who knew absolutely nothing about the past of his grandfather. This gentleman was an amateur geologist. Every Sunday he went to look for stones, collected them, split them. In addition, he hunted for butterflies, caught and killed them in a jar of cyanide. What could be more banal! However, this man felt very uncomfortable and tried to find a way to cope with his condition. He was treated by several doctors, including a psychoanalyst, but without much success. life. Then he turned to Nicolas Abraham, who came up with the idea to conduct a study of his family, going up several generations. And then he finds out that the patient had a grandfather (his mother’s father), about whom no one told him! advised the client to visit his grandfather's relatives. He found out that his grandfather had committed acts that were impossible to admit - he was suspected of robbing a bank and, perhaps, doing something even worse. He was sent to the African battalion, to the quarries, and then executed in the gas chamber. And the grandson knew nothing about it. What did our patient do on weekends? As an amateur geologist, he knocked off stones and, while hunting large butterflies, killed them in a jar of cyanide. The symbolic circle closes, he expresses a secret (that belonged to his mother), a secret unknown to himself."
The unwritten rules by which families live are also located within the collective unconscious. Moreover, patterns of family relationships can be passed down from generation to generation and greatly influence the lives of family members. Separately, the author’s position on unsightly and tragic incidents in family history should be mentioned. Schutzenberger believes that hushing up and avoiding mentioning these cases leads to the fact that the next generation in the family (grandchildren) will pay for what was done by their ancestors (grandfathers).
Among the undeniable advantages, we can mention examples and a detailed description of genograms. The case analysis is very detailed. Some examples are so interesting and colorful that at times you understand that life is richer and more interesting than any writer’s invention.
The disadvantages are that the material is poorly structured and the book is difficult to read for an unprepared reader. The book contains many examples that are interesting to read, however, they are not structured.
And be prepared for the fact that the book will change your view of your own family: you may well have a desire to get to know your ancestors better.

«. ..fathers ate sour grapes, and children’s teeth are set on edge.”

Book of the Prophet Ezekiel, chapter 18, verses 1-4

Hello to all “advanced” people, beginners and those simply interested in issues of psychology, or more precisely, issues of script reprogramming. Our Club has been dealing with this issue for many years and quite successfully. At the same time, quite often we encounter situations that are difficult to explain using the traditional approach. People begin to encounter inexplicable things, events begin to occur that cannot be explained from the point of view of the usual theory of scenarios.

Well, for example, how to explain the phenomenon that in a family, in each generation, it is the eldest child who dies, and all subsequent ones remain alive. Or is it such that a woman wakes up every night in terrible despair precisely from 5 to 6 in the morning, and then everything suddenly goes away? There are a great many similar examples.

Most people immediately rush to look for answers where they simply cannot be found. Fate, karma... Yes, such directions provide an “explanation”, and one is cooler than the other. You read it, and you don’t want to live at all

So what is it? Mysticism? Evil spirits? Or something else out of this world?

And everything is much simpler. This is science, the science of man and, more specifically, the science of our ancestors. Yes, yes exactly about them. Now let's go back to the very beginning.

Most areas of psychology, working with human script mechanisms, usually study in detail the life path of the client himself. There is an analysis of his early years of life, the influence of close people who had the greatest influence on the formation of his character, as well as how these mechanisms manifested themselves throughout his life. But besides this, there is one more mechanism that is usually not paid attention to - the scenarios of the “past”. Scenarios of our ancestors. Yes, exactly, the scripts of our grandmothers, great-grandmothers, etc. This trend in psychology is called the “Ancestor Syndrome.”

There is such a definition of this phenomenon.

Ancestor syndromethe coincidence of dates of significant events occurring in the same family over several generations, repetition of the circumstances of life and death, as well as the transfer “by inheritance” of unfulfilled family debt.

It's that simple. But it is still worth clarifying a number of points.

The effect of ancestral syndrome is associated with the “unconscious” of the family, which is invisibly present in the life of any person, from the moment of conception to death. How does it work? While still in the “project”, inside the mother, the child already becomes the object of expectations from his family: who the child will be born into, whose hopes he will justify by his birth, etc. Many parents want to find out the gender in advance in order to choose a name. Often, a father or mother wants to name a boy or girl in honor of their ancestor. And when the child is already born, they will certainly find “ancestral traits” in him.

If there is an external resemblance to one of the relatives, there are often expectations that the child will be similar to him in behavior and character traits (especially if we are talking about a family hero, a role model). But it also happens that this person is associated not with heroic deeds, but with bad memories. Then they try to talk about him less often or remain silent altogether: otherwise the child may follow in his footsteps. Alas, the mechanisms of the “ancestor syndrome” inevitably come into play here: if expectations turn into fears, the child will still unconsciously copy the behavior of the ill-fated relative.

It does not matter whether the expectations of relatives are expressed out loud or implied “by default.” The important thing is that they involuntarily form a “past scenario” for the child’s future life. And a family secret always only increases the likelihood that descendants will repeat the negative experience or difficult fate of family members who lived earlier.

A small example for reference.

A., 42 years old, auto mechanic at the service center of a large car dealer. His seven-year-old son was in a car accident. The accident occurred at the end of August. When analyzing the past, the following emerged. When A. was 7 years old and he was going to school for the first time, an accident occurred that frightened him greatly. Surprisingly, his father, when he was going to school for the first time, was involved in a traffic accident. But grandfather A. had no accidents on the way to school for the reason that he did not go there. His father was killed in World War II, the family was left without a livelihood, and his six-year-old son was sent to work in the fields on a collective farm instead of going to school. Since then, in every generation, the beginning of the school year has been marred by an incident on the way to school. And this is not an accident. The feeling of resentment that great-grandfather A. experienced when he was sent to do hard work instead of school began to be inherited. It caused an unconscious feeling of guilt in subsequent generations and a desire, as it were, to punish themselves for the opportunity to receive an education. Moreover, the following is especially striking in this situation: all accidents occur at the end of August, the beginning of September - the month when school starts

Something like this. But let’s not be sad, but let’s move on and slowly sort everything out.

What are the mechanisms of transmission of the “ancestral script”?

It is necessary to separate two forms of transmission of “family scripts”.

First– this is an inheritance from previous generations, based on personal communication (what we learned by communicating with our parents, grandparents, what family values ​​and attitudes they instilled in us during our upbringing). This form of transmission is largely based on the verbal mode of communication. And if from childhood a girl saw how her mother, grandmother (and great-grandmother too) lived according to the formula - “kitchen-husband-children”, then most likely her main asset will be: a Tefal frying pan, a Samsung vacuum cleaner, a couple of TV series, math homework and the Russian and the “eternal” hope that today “darling” will buy her flowers. And professional self-realization is unlikely to be a priority for her.

To recognize direct transmission signals, it is enough to analyze the most repeated phrases of your mother or grandmother. As a child was most often called in childhood - “oh, my beauty!” (programming for an extroverted style of behavior), “oh, my smart girl!” (bookmark of the importance of intellectual characteristics), “you are our firstborn and favorite!” (programming for a leadership position) - etc. Moreover, very often the assessment and expectations of parents can radically diverge from the true personal characteristics of the child. In addition, something like “in our family it is not customary to get married before the age of twenty-five” or “we are mental workers, there will never be artists or other comedians in our family” could often be said...

To move on to the second type of transmission, consider the following point.

Like most scenario moments, the “ancestor syndrome” refers to mechanisms that are unconscious to humans.

In 1978, two French psychoanalysts Nicolas Abraham and Maria Törek introduced the concept of “crypt” and “ghost”. The authors explained these phenomena as follows:

“A ghost is a formation of the “unconscious.” Its peculiarity is that it has never been conscious (that is, we may not know that there is some kind of secret, but our unconscious reads and perceives information that is a secret). The "ghost" is the result of transmission from the unconscious parent to the unconscious child.

“Ghost” is the work in the unconscious of the “secret” of another, the presence of which cannot be admitted (incest, crime, illegitimate child, ...). What obsessively haunts us is not the dead, but the gaps that remain in us due to the secrets of others. Its manifestation, its pursuit is the return of the “ghost” in strange words and actions, in symptoms and illnesses. This is how what is revealed and hidden is what rests as the “living and dead” science of the mystery of the other.”

A little powdery, now I’ll try “shorter” and “in Russian”! The unconscious is already present in the child when he is in the womb. And in this unconscious, a certain area is allocated (like a “black box”), where a “secret” or “ghost” is laid down, which then, throughout a person’s life, will periodically crawl into the light.

And now let's talk about second type of transmission!

Second type– transgenerational transmission. It occurs over several (sometimes very distant from each other) generations and is based on non-verbal language. To understand the mechanism of transgenerational transmission, one must understand the essence of family nonverbal attitudes. For example, you may not know anything about your great-grandmother because neither your mother nor grandmother ever said anything about her. But the subconscious is much more attentive than you; it does not miss a single gesture or action that indirectly reveals a connection between any event and your relative. Let's say a great-grandmother was widowed at 31, a year after the birth of her child. Moreover, somehow she caused the death of her husband and never remarried. Of course, the details of the tragedy in the family are kept silent. And even your grandmother may not know what happened to her father. But exactly one year after your mother was born, she divorces her husband. And she never gets married again. Your mother, in turn, loses her husband - your father. Would it be surprising that you still have not found marital happiness or have had experiences of failed relationships?

The attitudes of ancestors may be different. But no matter how they sound, they always evoke a high degree of trust in a person. After all, we hear them from early childhood and from the people who matter most to us.

What else would you like to say? As in traditional scenario theory, there are also several directions. I won't list them all. I will say the following as an example.

"Replacement child and restorative child"

“Inexplicable facts have also been noticed in cases where we are talking about a “replacement child,” that is, when a child is conceived to replace a recently deceased small child or relative. Often the newborn is named after the deceased and/or is born on the anniversary of the death, although no mourning has taken place. If this deceased is not remembered and mourned, then the life of the surrogate child is not in the happiest way...”

Anne Anseline Schutzenberger

The "strong word" effect

“Without believing in a curse, one might wonder about the effect of a strong word accompanying a strong emotion, especially coming from an authority figure—a priest, a parent, a teacher. It is precisely because of the unconscious nature of the influence of what is said or predicted that I do not trust astrology, fortune telling on cards, reading lines on the hand, clairvoyance, since no one knows whether the predicted misfortune is sometimes realized precisely because of the uttered strong word that in people's minds leads to failure, death, accident and thus makes them possible or predictable, thereby influencing changes in the body - space - time - future (this seems to bring the “automatic fulfillment of predictions” closer and, as it were, creates the stress of prophecy ). This is precisely what may be the evil eye, familiar to us from numerous fairy tales, legends, stories about sorcerers and the vicissitudes of fate. But stress can arise from a negative prediction; similarly, the situation can improve with a favorable prediction and a positive outlook...”

Anne Anseline Schutzenberger

"Anniversary Syndrome"

“The unconscious has a good memory, and it seems to us that it loves family connections and marks important events in the life cycle by repeating the date or age: this is the anniversary syndrome.

We have often observed that birth often occurs when it seems necessary to remember an important event in the family, sad or happy.

Many children are born as if to celebrate the anniversary (birth or death) of the mother’s mother (I deliberately say and write “mother’s mother”, not grandmother, since for the unconscious this changes the meaning. It hears what is said. ), as if recalling the mother's connection with her own mother (or father), the same place of birth - as if there was an agreement between the mother's unconscious and the preconscious of her unborn child that these birth dates would become significant.

Thus, it is often possible to decipher the meaning of a premature or late birth in relation to an important family member - dead or alive..."

Anne Anseline Schutzenberger

There are several other “past scenarios”. But the main question is:

“What should we do about it now?”

I will give several options for working with this syndrome. Please note that this is just an example, as... It is difficult to do this on your own.

  1. 1. If the family is a source of mental trauma, then many problems can be overcome by “plunging” into the history of family relationships and resolving the original conflicts there. If our destiny is connected with the history of our family, then we can “replay” the events of the past, weakening the influence of fatal circumstances. You can “meet” one of your ancestors, clarify your relationship with them, get permission or another message from them, using them as a resource. One of the techniques that solves such problems is the “parent interview”, borrowed from transactional analysis, which consists of treating the parental ego state and “clarifying” the relationship with the real parent. A psychodramatic “dialogue with an ancestor” is similar to a parental interview, but it has a different task - to weaken the harmful psychological connection with the problems of ancestors, to separate one’s own and other people’s destinies, or, for example, to free oneself from the “curse of the family.”
  1. 2. One form of working with early scenario decisions is the technique of “re-decision therapy,” which is well implemented using psychodrama techniques. For this purpose, there is an early childhood scene in which the child makes a scenario decision, which becomes the basis for future scenario beliefs. This scene needs to be replayed psychodramatically, helping the “child” make a new decision that “cancels” the previous harmful script beliefs. Using such techniques, you can work with any script prohibitions. To overcome the prohibition “don’t live,” for example, they “replay” the scene of a person’s birth, organizing the game in such a way that the person gets a new experience of being accepted by the world.
  1. 3. Many of our problems have a longer history and are related to the context of family history. We receive messages from the depths of our species, among them there are positive ones (playing the role of our resources) and negative ones (creating unconstructive fears and restrictions). Some of the positive resource messages do not reach us for various reasons. Like post restante parcels, they are waiting for their addressee. This occurs due to a disrupted communication system in the genus system, when important information is hushed up, repressed into the area of ​​the genus unconscious. A very interesting method is “reconstruction of the clan” - a synthesis of the methods of psychodrama and genosociogram, which allows you to work more fully with the clan system. With the help of a “recreated” family, you can solve many therapeutic problems, first of all, receive powerful resource support from your ancestors, accept initiation, “take” the positive from the group unconscious and “give” the negative, which in this way can be realized. A psychodramatic conversation with a significant ancestor, which is part of this technique, should consist of strengthening the resources that he gives us, and at the same time separating one’s fate from his fate, in autonomizing one’s own life.

I agree, much is not clear. And it is for this purpose that I am launching a training seminar and a series of webinars. In addition, based on the results of seminars and webinars, a contact group will be created where I will help sort out emerging issues.

In my opinion, in psychological practice, be it individual or group work, the context in which a person lives now and in which he grew up and was brought up is of great importance, first of all - the circumstances of the life of his family and clan as a whole. Without taking this information into account, psychological assistance may be incomplete and sometimes ineffective. As A.A. wrote Schutzenberger, " If we treat the individual without addressing the family as a whole, if we have not realized that transgenerational repetitions exist, then we have not done anything meaningful in therapy. At best we can only get temporary relief" On the contrary, taking this important information into account provides new opportunities for psychological interventions and provides resources for solving many problems that would be difficult to resolve without this context.

This entry was posted in. Bookmark the .

My research on genosociograms and anniversary syndrome Schutzenberger Anne Anselin

Anne Anseline Schutzenberger ANCESTOR SYNDROME. Transgenerational connections, family secrets, anniversary syndrome, transmission of trauma and practical use of the genosociogram

Anne Anseline Schutzenberger

ANCESTOR SYNDROME. Transgenerational connections, family secrets, anniversary syndrome, transmission of trauma and practical use of the genosociogram

(translated from French by I.K. Masalkov) M: publishing house of the Institute of Psychotherapy, 2001

1 (p.13)

It's safe to say that in our lives we less free than we think. However we can win our freedom and avoid repetitions, understanding what is happening, realizing these threads in their context and complexity. In this way, we can finally live “our own” life, and not the life of our parents or grandparents, or, for example, the deceased brother whom we “replaced”, sometimes without even realizing it... These complex connections between generations can be seen, felt or anticipate, at least in part. But most often we don’t talk about them: they are lived as elusive, unrecognized, unspoken or secret.

2 (p.168)

One of the most amazing examples- the life of the artist Vincent Van Gogh, born on March 30, 1852, exactly one year after the death of his older brother, also Vincent. The family did not want to talk about him, but the child was given his double name without changes - Vincent-Wilhelm. Vincent Van Gogh's life was tragic, as if someone forbade him to exist. His paternal half-brother, Theo, with whom he was very friendly and who loved him, got married. He had a child, and he named him Vincent-Wilhelm, precisely out of love for his brother. A few months later, Theo writes to his artist brother about his son: “I hope that this Vincent will live and be able to realize himself.” After receiving this letter, Vincent Van Gogh committed suicide. As if for him there could not be two living Vincent Van Goghs at the same time. It was as if his brother had pointed out to him the incompatibility of the presence of both.

3 (p.75)

Secret- this is always a problem.... Freud reminded us that he who has eyes to see and ears to hear states that mortals cannot keep any secrets. “The one whose lips remain silent blurts it out with his fingertips. He gives himself away at every pore.” This leads us to understand and properly appreciate the importance of non-verbal communication and expressing feelings both through body language and eloquent silence.

4 (p.68)

Nicolas Abraham(1968) tells the story of a patient who knew absolutely nothing about his grandfather's past. This gentleman was an amateur geologist. Every Sunday he went to look for stones, collected them, and split them. In addition, he hunted for butterflies, caught them and killed them in a jar of cyanide. What could be more banal! However, this person felt very uncomfortable and tried to find a way to cope with his condition. He was treated by several doctors, including a psychoanalyst, but without much success. He felt uncomfortable in life. Then he turned to Nicolas Abraham, who came up with the idea to conduct research on his family, rising several generations higher. And then he finds out that the patient had a grandfather (mother’s father), about whom no one told! It was a secret. The therapist advised the client to visit his grandfather's relatives. He found out that his grandfather had committed acts that were impossible to admit to - he was suspected of robbing a bank and, perhaps, doing something even worse. He was sent to the African battalion, to the quarries, and then executed in the gas chamber. And the grandson knew nothing about it. What did our patient do on weekends? As an amateur geologist, he knocked off stones and, while hunting large butterflies, killed them in a jar of cyanide. The symbolic circle closes, he expresses a secret (that belonged to his mother), a secret unknown to himself.

5 (p.31)

This leads to the concepts justice and family justice. When justice is not observed, it manifests itself in unbelief, exploitation of some members by others (sometimes in flight, revenge, revenge), even in illness or accidents. Conversely, when justice is observed, there is affection, mutual respect among family members, "family accounts" are conducted carefully. We can talk about "family account balance" And "family ledger", where credit and debit, debts, responsibilities, merits are visible. Otherwise, we have a number of problems that repeat from generation to generation.

6 (p.37)

This is where you can see, as Alain Mijolla showed, to what extent the family problems, for example, of the poet Arthur Rimbaud, prevented him from living: he was unable to solve them, and he fled. One of his problems was the departure of his father, a military man, when the boy was 6 years old. But if we turn to previous generations, the same fact is observed: a hundred years earlier, his great-grandfather left his son at 6 years old, and paternal men continued to leave their sons at the same age, leaving or dying: these were “unpaid bills of the original family." It is this reactivation at the same age that Josephine Hilgard calls anniversary syndrome or “double anniversary” (if the phenomenon repeats with each of the children).

7 (p.146)

In every person's life there are bad periods, black series of troubles and failures. People don’t know what’s tormenting them, they feel uneasy, they don’t sleep well, they don’t feel well, they catch any infection, they get the flu, or a minor traffic accident, or a sprained ankle, or something more serious, and sometimes fatal. They often experience malaise, which cannot be detected by either an x-ray or a blood test. They experience a streak of failures without knowing why. They go to doctors who reveal nothing. But sometimes they are diagnosed with cancer or urgently need surgery, and something happens to them during the operation or post-operative complications arise. When compiling genosociograms, that is, a family tree on which important life events, dates and ages are noted, one can notice that very often all this happens during the same period and at the same age at which someone in their family died or separated from someone something, or was in the hospital. […] Let us recall that President Kennedy himself refused to put a bulletproof top on his car in Dallas on November 22, 1963, “forgetting” about the threat of death and the fact that his grandfather’s father Patrick died on November 22, 1858. He forgot about this event , but didn’t forget to take risks.

8 (p.105)

Starting formulate historical-economic-sociological hypotheses, you notice that if before this time the client said that he could not remember anything, then at this moment you can say that some kind of “latch” opened in his head, and he will now exclaim: “Oh, yes, this However, I remember that the family became very poor not during the Panama events, it happened at the time of the Suez Canal events, when (my father or my grandmother) changed schools because complications arose.” Entire blocks of memory suddenly open up- simply because, so to speak, the locks have been removed from the memory zones: free associations begin to arise, and people are able to remember extremely significant things that they knew without knowing it. After this, they will be able to remember that they knew a great-aunt, a neighbor of their godmother or grandmother, a regimental friend of their grandfather, with whom the great-aunt is still in contact... They will finally be able to make inquiries.

9 (p.112)

I became together with Helen look for the meaning of her name and suggested that it could be an abbreviation - L.N., “el”, “en” (Americans like to give names with initials). I thought that we were talking about a secret reminder, about a travesty name, about a secret meaning that needs to be unraveled, about initials. Then I advised her to look at the list of professors and teachers who might have worked at that college during her mother’s studies. Helen searched for names on L.N. and found a certain Louis Nicolas. She went to him and asked if he knew her mother. It turned out that this man was indeed her father; he did not know that the student had become pregnant from him, and was happy that he had a daughter.

10 (p. 161, 164)

Not believing in a curse, you can think about the effect strong words, accompanying a strong emotion, especially coming from an authority figure - a priest, doctor, parent, teacher. […] During the revolution, the peasants of Savoy hid the priest, but after the terror he came out of hiding. He thanked them and blessed them, saying: “Let the eldest child in every generation be your guardian.” Since then, for two centuries, the eldest child in each generation has become, as it were, a “heavenly angel” and guards their peace. … I talked at length with this lady and explained that everything can be understood differently, that there is a difference between a blessing and a curse, that the phrase “The eldest child in each generation will be your keeper” can be interpreted differently depending on the frame of reference used. ... You can take care of your family in different ways... Either treat (doctor, nurse), or be a useful member of society, an assistant. So we put the phrase and the prediction in another semantic frame. Since then, something has changed in her vision, in her life, and the baby has recovered. Ten years later, she is still alive and well. For the first time since the revolution, the eldest child in the family does not die. The repetition of events in every generation for two hundred years - how is this possible? Why? What's happening? Where is this recorded in the family and personal unconscious? How is the transfer carried out?

11 (p.182)

To put it simply, at birth and even in the womb the child receives a certain number of messages: he is given his last name and first name, expectations of roles that he will have to play or avoid. These role expectations can be positive and/or negative. For example, the idea that he is “a copy of his grandfather’s brother Jules” may be projected onto a child, and everyone around him begins to think that he will be an adventurer, a “disreputable citizen,” like his grandfather. The child will be made a scapegoat; he will not be “put on the clothes of the deceased”, whom he will have to replace. Like the fairies around the cradle of Sleeping Beauty, they will predict a lot of things for him - instructions, scenarios, the future. This will be said explicitly or will remain unspoken and will be implied “by default” and kept strictly confidential. However, explicit or implicit expectations will “program” the child.

12 (p.188)

...with the current level of knowledge we, clinicians, should observe and describe these phenomena - say, strange cases of transmission from one unconscious to another, collect facts, clinical descriptions, publish them, conduct clinical and at the same time statistical studies (as Josephine Hilgard was able to do on the anniversary syndrome). Then, perhaps, understanding these “phantoms” of the unconscious, these “repetitions”, “anniversaries”, will bring us closer to understanding interacting beings who have intuition and language, i.e. us. The dead man grabs the living, as the saying goes and Roman law.

http://www.psy-analyst.ru/autoref/3schut8.asp

From the book Dream - secrets and paradoxes author Vein Alexander Moiseevich

From the book 12 Christian beliefs that can drive you crazy by Townsend John

“Me and God” syndrome Don’t accuse Roy of irresponsibility, madness or lack of faith. Let's delve into this problem, because it is faced by many Christians who ask much the same questions. In some ways, this belief is easier to cope with than the false one

From the book Change your brain - your life will change! by Amen Daniel

Tourette's syndrome Tourette's syndrome (TS) is a very curious disorder, a kind of link between the basal ganglia and two seemingly unrelated disorders - attention deficit disorder (ADD) and obsessive-compulsive disorder

From the book of the Goddess in every woman [New psychology of women. Goddess Archetypes] author Jin Shinoda is sick

Medea Syndrome The term “Medea Syndrome” aptly describes the vengeful Hera woman who feels deceived and abandoned by her husband and goes to extremes for revenge. The myth of Medea provides a metaphor for the ability of the female Hera to make her commitment to

From the book My Research on Genosociograms and Anniversary Syndrome author Schutzenberger Anne Anselin

Anne Anseline Schutzenberger MY RESEARCH IN GENOSOCIOGRAMS AND ANNIVERSARY SYNDROME I began to be interested in this topic about twelve years ago, impressed by a remark made by my daughter. She told me: "Mom, do you realize that you are the eldest of two children

From the book The Oxford Manual of Psychiatry by Gelder Michael

From the book Ancestor Syndrome: transgenerational connections, family secrets, anniversary syndrome, transmission of trauma and the practical use of genosociogram / Transl. I.K. Masalkov - Moscow: Publishing House of the Institute of Psychotherapy: 2001 To the therapists of the Philadelphia school, which introduced

From the book Freud: A Case History author Lyukimson Petr Efimovich

From the book Lateness and Broken Promises author Krasnikova Olga Mikhailovna

From the book How to overcome shyness author Zimbardo Philip George

Imposter Syndrome One of the most counterintuitive reasons for not keeping promises is fear of success. Fear of failure is understandable and logical. Few people want to feel guilty, receive confirmation of their inferiority, or be punished for their mistake, so if

From the book Mindsight. The New Science of Personal Transformation by Siegel Daniel

The Superiority Syndrome The American value system, with its emphasis on competition and personal achievement, also contributes to the prevalence of shyness. In the words of James Dobson, in our country human beauty is a gold coin, intelligence is a silver coin;

From the book The Path of Least Resistance by Fritz Robert

Using Hippocampal Functions to Heal Trauma Alison first came to see me because of persistent relationship difficulties, including serious problems in her sex life. She was thirty-one years old then. When I asked about her childhood, she said,

From the book Understanding Risks. How to choose the right course author Gigerenzer Gerd

Prisoner Syndrome Shortly before release, prisoners often lose sleep and experience anxiety. Oddly enough, symptoms appear after years of waiting for the day when they will be released. Similar anxiety arises in anticipation of some events

From the book The Story of Your Future author Kovalev Sergey Viktorovich

SNK syndrome Do patients know that many doctors do not understand test results? Are patients aware that doctors use the defensive medical practices discussed in Chapter 3? As far as I know, in very rare cases. For example,

From the book I Think Too Much [How to Use Your Over-Efficient Mind] author Peticollen Christel

Fate depends on the conscious upbringing of parents and their unconscious program of the family, “karma of the kind”.

Does the apple fall far from the tree?

The destiny program is a gradually unfolding unconscious plan received with genes from parents and constantly reinforced by information from early childhood, mainly under the influence of the parents’ lifestyle. The program of fate is that psychological impulse that with great force pushes a person along the path of leading the same lifestyle as his parents. Just as birds teach their chicks to fly, so adults pass on experience to children in how they relate to themselves, people, problems, etc. But sometimes a child receives a program in the form of attitudes that do not correspond to what he sees in life. For example, a mother teaches her son: “Don’t be like your father! Don't drink wine! If you drink, I’ll kill you!” The son himself, seeing his drunken father, can promise not to drink.

There is no doubt that the program of fate is influenced by the beliefs, attitudes, and covenants that the child receives from loved ones. Sometimes there are negative attitudes even on a conscious level (see fate "Cursed")

There is also an unconscious program, “kinship karma,” which is written about in the book “The Ancestor Syndrome.”

Excerpts from the book by Schutzenberger A.
Ancestor Syndrome: Transgenerational connections, family secrets,

and practical use of the genosociogram,

2001.- 240 p.


“Each of us is a link in the chain of generations, and sometimes we have to, to our own surprise, “pay the debts” of our ancestors. This kind of “invisible devotion to family” pushes us to unconsciously repeat pleasant situations or sad events. We are less free than we think, but we have the opportunity to win our freedom and avoid fatal repetitions in our family history by understanding the complex intricacies in our own family. This book went through 14 editions in France. It is the result of twenty years of scientific activity and clinical practice of Anne Anseline Schutzenberger. The cases that she cites, in terms of drama, emotional intensity and mystery, surpass the wildest fantasies of the authors of Gothic novels. Sometimes they shock, sometimes they pierce with acute pain and always remind us that each of us is part of a common history for all and even the most distant events are much closer to an individual than one might imagine. The research and therapeutic aspect of the book presents the rationale for those phenomena that the author works with using his method - transgenerational psychogenealogical conceptual therapy. One of its main “tools” - genosociograms - allows you to unravel a complex tangle of family stories, identify connections between generations and break the chain of unconscious repetitions so that a person can realize his own purpose and take advantage of his chance in life.

Anne Anseline Schutzenberger

MY RESEARCH OF GENOSOCIOGRAMS
AND ANNIVERSARY SYNDROME

I began to become interested in this topic about twelve years ago, inspired by a remark made by my daughter. She told me: “Mom, do you realize that you are the eldest of two children (the second child died), and dad is the eldest of two, the second child died, and I am the eldest of two children, the second child died... and since then, When Uncle Jean-Paul died, I was to some extent afraid of the death of my brother...” (And so it happened.)

I was shocked. This is true, and the fact that we were talking about accidents, about road incidents, did not change the situation, rather the opposite.

Then I began to sort through all my relatives in my memory and discovered repeated cases of death: my goddaughter is an “orphan by heredity.” Her mother was already an orphan at a young age, and so was her daughter. My beloved grandfather also became an orphan at an early age, being the eldest child in the family.

Then I began searching among my husband’s relatives in the Alsatian archives and in the south of France, among my mother-in-law’s relatives (she was also the eldest child in a family where the second child died). I used family research carried out by a “cousin curé” in Marseilles as part of my dissertation, and then archival research carried out in Provence and Paris by a real genealogist. And all in order to find out the genealogy of grandparents for my grandchildren. What a big surprise it was to discover roots in Normandy, near the place where the parents of their daughter’s husband accidentally bought a house, “while passing through there.” There I found the roots of my mother-in-law’s family - the surnames were similar: a hundred years ago both families had the same surname, right down to the last letter - a coincidence and an accident, of course.

Another reason for this orientation of my research is related to a letter that I accidentally received, although it was not intended for me. My mother-in-law was writing to her best friend and “by mistake” (according to Freud) put the letter in an envelope with my name and address. Since the letter began with the address “My dear,” I read it to the end until I realized that it was not addressed to me. My dear mother-in-law wrote that her son’s marriage to a “stranger” surprised her and that she felt with me like a “black woman from the plateau,” since we are very far from each other in terms of culture and environment. This surprised me, because we are both Parisians, both from medical families and teachers of medicine at the university. Then I understood what an “introduced detail” was in a traditional family whose ancestors participated in the Crusades.

The daughter-in-law forever remains “introduced” (stranger). This allowed me to look into oral traditions and unwritten family rules. True, I eventually became a “son” for my father-in-law (in his family it was customary that women do not work, but in mine * they do) - I followed in his footsteps, received an “inheritance” from him: I also became engage in psychotherapy and fell in love with him Alsace. But from my mother-in-law from Provence, I “adopted and accepted” only olive oil in salad, but I was never truly accepted. My daughter (although born in Paris) studied at the University of Strasbourg, “returning there after a hundred years” 1.

Discovery of anniversary syndrome

Another reason for my turning in research to the personal and family, to what I casually called psychogenealogy 2 and, mainly, anniversary syndrome 3- this is a case that I noted about fifteen years ago. At that time I was just beginning to work with people with terminal cancer using the Simonton method - as I understood it in 1975, until his first book appeared. I was surprised to discover severe cancer in a happy, thriving newlywed (she did not experience very much stress) at the same age (thirty-five years old) when her mother died of cancer.

Since then, I have always conducted a systematic search in the family history when caring for a patient: are there any repeating events or manifestations of “unconscious, hidden loyalty to the family,” unconscious identification of oneself with a key, important member of the family... And I often found such cases - cancer in the same age as the mother, grandfather, maternal aunt, godmother, when they died from this disease or accident.

These very numerous clinical observations, this intuition, were confirmed by statistical studies on anniversary syndrome carried out by Josephine Hilgard. I learned about these studies in 1991 - 1992.

Josephine Hilgard (physician and psychologist), studying cards of all patients, admitted to one American clinic for several years (1954 - 1957), proved that the sudden onset of psychosis in patients in adulthood could be associated with a repetition in the family of a traumatic event suffered in childhood - the loss of a mother or father due to her ( his) death, placement in a psychiatric clinic or accident. When repeating the context, when a child grows up and he himself turns the same age as his parent was (when he, for example, ended up in a psychiatric hospital), and his own child turns the same age as he himself was when his mother, to for example, died or was hospitalized (double anniversary), - hospitalization in a medical institution is repeated, and this is “statistically significant.”

I used both the family tree and sociometric connections and what Moreno allegedly called a genosociogram in an old conversation that I don’t remember well 4 (but it was remembered by a medical student who talked about this in Dakar with my colleague and friend Professor Henri Collomb after returning from America). Some of us returned to this legacy in Nice in 1980, and it can also be traced in part to the work of another of Moreno's students, Nathan Ackerman, who practices family therapy in the United States.

"Children and pet dogs know everything..."

The fourth reason for my interest is the first conversation I had with Françoise Dolto, a very long time ago, when, after finishing my university studies in the United States, I asked her to attend my first group psychodrama classes as a supervisor. She asked: “Were your grandmother and great-grandmother liberated women or decent and frigid?” To my protest that I don’t know this and can’t know, she objected: “In a family, children and dogs always know everything, especially what they don’t talk about.”

This discussion by Françoise Dolto became my first introduction to the field of the “transgenerational method” and unintentional, unconscious familial “transmission”.

Exchanges and interaction

Fascinating discussions with Margaret Mead (in 1956) and Gregory Bateson (in 1972) opened my eyes to anthropological approach and method observations of natural behavior, which developed in France in the course of formal and informal meetings on “human ethology” with Hubert Montaner, Jacques Cosnier and, mainly, with Boris Barber. Frequent lunches (on a detour through San Francisco) with Jürgen Ruesch (between 1957 and 1975) opened my eyes to the realm of the "non-verbal", to body language, interaction and how, when observed up close, one can almost guess what people think and feel - by their nonverbal behavior, facial expressions and gestures, kinesthetics, proxemia, harmony and synchrony of movements.

This work on nonverbal communication deepened what I began to do in 1950 in psychodrama with J.L. Moreno and especially with Jim Enneis, observing, imitating and using body language in mirroring, and mainly the method duplication the protagonist, his “second self”, alter ego. The work continued for ten years through searches and observations, study of video recordings. It became the topic of my doctoral dissertation at the Sorbonne on nonverbal communication (1975).

My working style

For me it's a genosociogram , transgenerational contextual psychogenealogy is a clinical work of observation and synthesis that takes place in close collaboration between the “client” (in the sense in which Rogers uses the term) and the “psi” doctor (psychotherapist, psychoanalyst, psychiatrist, etc.). The clinician is expected to be very respectful of the client's background, have a keen sense of hearing and vision, and be able to simultaneously focus his or her interest on the client, his story, his speech, and other modes of expression (eg, nonverbal communication). He listens to what the client says and observes what the client “translates” through feelings and emotions, and at the same time keeps his mental associations in the spotlight, using his countertransference and experiences. The doctor must simultaneously keep the other (client) in the spotlight and listen to his “personal radar” - think quickly, grasp his own associations on the fly, use knowledge in the field of sociology, economics, history, art, in order, if necessary, to build hypotheses and ask questions and thus “reveal” and “talk” to the client. And all this in order to “grab and pull the red thread”, structure, configuration, pattern the client's family life and his personal life in the context and language that is characteristic and distinctive of his family's past and his myths in this particular family in the broad sense of the word.

For this I use my clinical practice as a psychoanalyst (classical, in the spirit of Freud), group analyst and psychodrama therapist, my “field” experience as a psychologist-sociologist, clinician and anthropologist who worked on four continents, my habit of listening, observing, my experience in the field of verbal and non-verbal communication - indirect expression of feelings using body language, posture, facial expressions and gestures, micro-compression of muscles, rhythm, stopping and resumption of breathing, way of moving, sitting down and standing up, preferences in color, clothing, jewelry, hairstyle, haircut, jewelry, synchronized gestures, opening or closing the body (when arms are crossed or a briefcase is placed in front of oneself). And all this in order to somehow reveal what seems to me significant.

And on the basis of this significant thing, I try to “talk” to the client and encourage him to make associations in the process of working with himself and his family members (in a special psychotherapeutic space).

At the first stage, I listen to a client who talks about himself and his family, drawing his family tree with comments on the board (for group work) or on a piece of paper (for an individual conversation and anamnesis).

Thus, I use a technique based on composing family tree, supplemented by important life events: marriage, widowhood, divorce, birth of a child, care of children, moving, death, breakup, separation from one’s own (moving, care of a house helper/nurse/nanny). I have been using the Holmes and Reich Life Events Questionnaire for about fifteen years now. During this time I added to it. Using a questionnaire, I establish the “loss of a love object” and the coincidence of ages and dates, synchrony and diachrony (anniversary or double anniversary syndrome, for example, the age of the mother and the age of the daughter at the time of mourning or breakup), as well as the repetition of this configuration in the next generation or after one generation (work is carried out over three to five generations) to identify a disease or accident, especially during surgery. I use the method of psychogenealogy or genosociogram when preparing for surgery or to combat a serious illness, as well as to prevent or overcome school delays.

To listening I add my interest in history and historical, artistic, socio-economic facts, political, cultural, military, even sporting events that are important to the subject, events that help color context and often give it additional meaning.

I think it's important listen and watch, as Freud put it, with “floating attention” and to be, as Carl Rogers said, focused on the subject so as to enter his personal world and see it, as Moreno said, “with his own eyes,” and hear it with his “third ear.”

This way you can hear what the client is saying and help him give it form: clarify his goals, his life path, his difficulties, identity or rather identification and counter-identification, preferences and aversions, his model of the world.

The client draws this up on a board or a piece of paper, and we help him, sometimes asking at the right moment and/or encouraging him to express associations, following the “red thread” of his (our) associations or connections (this is how we use co-unconscious the one being helped and the one helping, as well as the group).

The genosociogram is more complex than the genogram. It identifies sociometric connections, context, important events, using, among other things, past experiences and the unconscious of the therapist and client (his dreams, slips of the tongue, erroneous actions, free associations).

I'm thinking integrative way, so I use it at the same time several conceptual models.

1. Psychoanalytic concept hidden loyalty to family Ivana Buzormeni-Nadia. In particular, identifying this loyalty or unconscious identification with a family member, often tragically dead or missing. I also follow his ideas about “debts and merits”, about the “book of family accounts” and “justice - injustice”.

This brings me to identifying the hidden grudges in clients, grievances, associated with the fact that one of the family members or neighbors took something away from them ... the possible restoration of what was lost, especially if we are talking about attempts to regain a status lost by one of the relatives (part of class neurosis) - a relative, grandfather , great-grandfather. This could be education, a house, a farm, a factory, or even a return to a particular area, city or village.

This is important, even years or centuries later, as atonement for the Armenian genocide or the desire of the Muslim Arabs to reclaim more territory: after all, eight centuries later, they are still talking about it.

2. Abraham and Török concepts related to “ crypt" And " ghost”, which is “introduced” into the descendant as a result of trauma, often caused by unjust events (a relative who died near Verdun in the war of 1914-1918, or died from gases in the trenches, or was left without burial). “Crypt” and “ghost” are often associated with family secrets that are considered shameful (murder, incest, prison, institutionalization, ruin, illegitimate children, tuberculosis, cancer or AIDS, losing at cards, loss of family fortune).

3. Family unions with the exception of some members ( triangulation Murray Bowen).

4. "Replacement children", i.e. children who were conceived to replace someone who had died (usually a child who died in early childhood, but sometimes a close relative). I establish correspondence and mark connections on the genosociogram by date, as well as by age, and am interested in those births that are associated with mourning (usually for the father or mother). Sometimes we can talk about “imperfect mourning” (Andre Green gave the example of a “dead mother”, i.e. a mother who was depressed, or mourning at the time of the birth of a child, which means that for him she seemed to be absent, was like “ dead.")

Replacement children” (imperfect mourning) are different from “ children - restorers”, who are received very well and are given a place of honor in the family.

5. School failures in capable children, associated with class neurosis, i.e. fear or ambivalence - to surpass both parents and/or to break away from them socially and then professionally. These failures are often due to the difficulty that children experience in reaching a cultural level that their parents did not achieve (for example, failing the baccalaureate examination), and the parents' unconscious ambivalence about their social advancement, which is perceived as a "betrayal" of their class or environment of origin.

6. I pay special attention anniversary syndrome: birth, wedding, illness or death may occur around (by age and date) the anniversary of an event important to the family or individual - loss due to death, institutionalization or separation of a loved one - a family member or friend, or any other "object" love." This could be the anniversary of a happy event (wedding, birth of children, receiving prizes, awards, holiday).

I get involved and often take action using four steps:

a) observe, look, listen very carefully; give the floor to the client, who builds his family tree, his genosociogram from memory;

b) identify an important sign - verbal or non-verbal, often subliminal;

c) give meaning to this feature, which is considered significant and important (this is working with many and different referents), then ask a series of leading questions to the working subject;

d) establish a dynamic connection between meaning and sign, use this connection to advance the subject towards his goals, desires, his model of the world. For this I moving from attentive listening to active dialogue, in order to “connect” to what seems effective for the subject and his environment, using various “grids” of interpretation. In other words, we are dealing with integrative psychotherapy and interaction.

Material details of constructing a genosociogram

It takes some time to build your genosociogram from memory based on your family tree.

With our way of working, we spend two to three hours per person to “analyze” the situation and present it graphically (with the help of a genosociogram), to find a guiding thread - “Ariadne’s thread” that can be pulled.

During the first individual conversation with a person who has a problem that needs to be solved or with a seriously ill person, I take it in the late morning or late afternoon so that the stipulated time can be exceeded. The doctors who have worked with us expect an hour and a half for the first conversation, for example, with a cancer patient, and the opportunity to take part of the time from their lunch break.

Anniversary Syndrome

The unconscious has a good memory and, it seems to us, it loves family ties and marks important life cycle events with repetition date or age: this anniversary syndrome.

We have often observed that birth often happens when it seems like you need to be reminded of an important event in the family, sad or happy.

Many children are born as if to celebrate an anniversary(birthday or death) of the mother’s mother, as if recalling the mother’s connection with her own mother (or father), the same place of birth - as if there was an agreement between the mother’s unconscious and the preconscious of her unborn child that these dates the birth of steel significant.

Thus, it is often possible to decipher the meaning of a premature or late birth in relation to an important family member - dead or alive.

Many replacement children are born day after day on the anniversary of the birth, death or funeral of the previous small child, whose mother did not mourn for him. Let us recall that psychoanalyst Andre Green found many cases of schizophrenia in replacement children born from a “dead mother”, i.e. sad, depressed, or in mourning (A. Green, “ Dead mother"). Her presence is little felt (she seems to have died). Quite often there are people who, at the end of their lives, “wait to say goodbye to everyone”, their birthday (say, 60, 80, 95 years old) and the family holiday planned for this, or the wedding of a granddaughter, or the return of a son from a trip.

After a critical, sad, difficult or dramatic event, such as sudden death young parents as a result of an accident, or the mother's placement in a clinic, often several years later an accident occurs, a serious physical illness occurs (for example, cancer), a psychotic attack (a daughter or son gets sick, has an accident, is admitted to a psychiatric clinic at the same age , in which there was a deceased parent). This can happen on the anniversary day (at the same age), or ten or fifty years later. This is often the case double anniversary: a child who becomes a parent and reaches the same age as his deceased parent, and at the same time his own child becomes the same age as himself at the time of loss.

Josephine Hilgard used the term anniversary to designate these specific cases of psychotic episodes marking the age of loss of a parent and double anniversary if there is a child of the same age.

I understand the term much more broadly anniversary syndrome, because I often watched repetitions accidents, marriages, miscarriages, deaths, illnesses, pregnancies... at the same age in two, three, five, eight generations (i.e., “going deeper” into family history by about two hundred years).

It is easy to pass through two centuries when a child knows his great-grandmother and she tells him about her childhood and about her own great-grandmother. This is how living stories about the Revolution or Napoleon’s campaigns are born - based on the stories of elderly relatives, a portrait, a medallion, a painting, furniture, letters, the Bible...

I extensively illustrate my arguments with clinical cases and life stories (see “Life Stories” below).

Participation in an event, even through one's death, 6 can be unconsciously played out in different ways. Some fathers and mothers wait until their son's return or their daughter's wedding to give themselves permission to die.

American historians have noted that the second and third US presidents, Thomas Jefferson (1743-1826) and John Adams (1735-1826), died on the same day (July 4, 1826), which is the fiftieth anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence (July 4, 1776). ). It's like they were waiting for this date to take part in the event celebrating the fiftieth anniversary and then passing through “death.”

Some family or historical coincidences can you better understand how reactions to anniversaries, How anniversary syndrome and, I would say, as an expression family and social transgenerational unconscious.

Some people every year at the same time experience feeling of anxiety and depression - why, they themselves don’t know. They do not remember that this is the anniversary of the death of a loved one - a relative or friend, and cannot establish a conscious relationship between these repeated facts.

Many people underwent surgery on the anniversary of the death or accident of a father, brother, or relative. This random coincidence is discovered, for example, after postoperative complications.

That is why I have always considered it important to tell family doctors, surgeons, oncologists, psychotherapists, and social workers about anniversary syndrome to help them work with their patients, since it is very common cases of physical and mental vulnerability during anniversary periods with poorly understood symptoms that are unclear until they are clarified anniversary connection.

American physician George Engel studied this phenomenon on himself (1975). He described, for example, his heart attack on the anniversary of his brother's sudden death(forty-nine years old) due to cardiac arrest. And on the first anniversary of his death, he himself had a serious heart attack. It is possible to hypothesize that there was an unconscious identification with the brother that caused the same physical reaction to anniversary stress(fear of death). He reacted in the same way, although to a lesser extent. George Engel survived and told us about it. He published an article describing his anxiety during that period (he was also forty-nine years old). He went through another anxious period associated with anniversary syndrome, with fear of dying at the same age as my father(at fifty-eight years old); unconsciously he "chose to forget" this age in order to survive.

Exactly this one difficult time period - the same age at which they died father, brother, mother and other loved one, I call period of vulnerability associated with "anniversary stress"(See the example of two brothers, Bernard and Lucien, who lived and died).

Often sudden death in different generations it subsequently makes itself felt in family history through accidents. Their severity diminishes over the course of one hundred to one hundred and fifty years, as, for example, in the story of the accident during the Battle of Sevastopol, or in the story of the boy Roger and the beginning of the school year, or with the birth of children on the same day in subsequent generations (for example, grandchildren of those who were wounded at Verdun). They were born on February 21, 1996 or November 11. This form of invisible loyalty.

Thus, we are dealing with a reminder of a suffering grandfather or great-uncle, wounded or killed in the war. And the torment and trauma of war and the cessation of fighting after the armistice on November 11, 1918 make themselves felt through birth or involuntary miscarriages *.

"Invisible loyalties" and "fractals"

As I have already clarified, anniversary syndrome can be either a case of repetition of one or another family event on the same date or at the same age, or an endless repetition of the same thing in several generations (and sometimes throughout the life of one person ). Sometimes we are talking about a happy event, and sometimes it is traumatic and difficult for the family. Sometimes we (myself and some others) managed to interrupt the chain of events (see presented clinical cases). However, the problem of finding answers to questions remains Why? And How? What explanation can be offered?

Since 1950, I had been closely following the work of Benoit Mandelbrot, and it occurred to me that these repetitions were related to “fractals.” Moreover, in 1999, several specialists in “chaos theory” and “fractals” approached me. They believed that my work with severely ill individuals and anniversary syndrome was, or could be, a skillful application of fractal theory to solve health problems. Ivan Guerrini (a professor from the state of Brazil, an expert in chaos theory) argues that the endless repetition of the same thing is a “fractal”, just like the winding contours of the coast of Brittany, the configuration of a snowflake, the head of a cauliflower, the beat of our heart (research Benoit Mandelbrot, 1975, 1959 - 1997). Of course, it is good and natural when there is an endless repetition of heart beating (this is a sign of life) or cell reproduction, but what happens when something suddenly goes wrong and an endless repetition of cancer cells begins (and this leads to death)? What has changed? Although we can say that nothing has changed.

Exactly theories of chaos and fractals can suggest that the smallest event can change “everything” (a classic example is the 1970 weather forecaster Edward Lorenz's account of the flapping of a butterfly's wings (butterfly effect). So, the very fact of a butterfly flapping its wings in the Amazon can lead to a tornado in Texas, which was confirmed by examples of phenomena that have both a natural scientific and complex nature: the state of the stock exchange, traffic on highways, the dynamics of ions and water in the soil, human blood circulation , economic crises and depressions (in the economy), football competitions, etc. I would like to give a clear and very simple example.

I wrote that I don’t believe in randomness (no psychoanalyst believes in this) and yet... One day I was sitting at home in front of the computer screen and printing this text in one copy. When the receiver ran out of paper, the computer issued a corresponding signal. Without turning away from the screen, I extended my left hand, tucked in the paper and... to my great surprise, the pages began to turn over, falling into the basket. Why? I didn’t move in my chair, it seemed like “nothing” had changed. And yet something happened, “stopping” one sequence and starting another. But why? “Nothing has changed” that I could be aware of.

In the area where all of us (I, along with dear readers) are specialists (we are talking about transgenerational phenomena), there have been cases of cessation of severe diseases (this happened in some cases of cancer at the final stage: after some work, metastases and cancer cells disappeared) in as a result of “decoding” the anniversary syndrome and family loyalty or “cannonball wind trauma”, severe trauma, imperfection? real mourning after an absurd death (of a person or animal from one’s circle or family circle). To do this, a circle is drawn that “attracts” repetitions (“ attractor"), one or another trend in behavior. However, the task of scientific substantiation (using the latest achievements of science and interdisciplinary approaches) and a more complete explanation of the phenomena of repetition and “attractors” has still not been solved.

Download the book Schutzenberger A. Ancestor Syndrome: Transgenerational connections, family secrets,
anniversary syndrome, trauma transmission
and practical use of the genosociogram http://psylib.myword.ru/index.php?automodule=downloads&showfile=1452

(for download rights you must register on the forum http://psylib.myword.ru)



Did you like the article? Share with your friends!