This guide will cover dictionaries and translators for Android. By the way, this topic was touched upon in. The review aspects are:
- Language support. It is important that at least two languages are supported: Russian and English - initially or by adding dictionaries.
- Offline and online functions. First of all, it is offline opportunities that are of interest, although online ones may also be present, which will be mentioned.
- Working with a dictionary: connection, speech synthesis or support for audio recordings, transcription.
- Search: taking into account morphology, inaccurate search, search speed.
- Additional features: phrasebook, contextual translation, integration with other applications.
Review participants:
- Google Translate
- GoldenDict
- Fora Dictionary
- ColorDict
- "Offline dictionaries"
Google Translate
In the latest versions of the official Google Translate client greatest attention focused specifically on offline translation. Therefore, now the application can be compared with other offline dictionaries using the same criteria.
First, let’s talk about offline features. Google Translate offers a choice of 80 languages that can be connected through the settings: just select the necessary dictionary from the list.
Google Translate is the least “academic”; it differs from the traditional Android dictionary both in its interface and in the form of results. When translating a term, the transcription is not displayed, for irregular verbs form not specified, other background information is also missing. Division into parts of speech is carried out, but not always (the principle of dictionary output remains unclear).
Google Translate is not least a user-friendly interface. It looks optimal in mobile version, less advantageous in . Easy navigation, nice animation. However, there is one flaw: when switching from portrait to landscape mode, only the translation is displayed, which, in fact, is a useless distribution of space.
Additional conveniences are noted when working with dictionaries. During translation, voice-over is available (online function). You can translate entire combinations, but, for the reason limited vocabulary, the implementation of this function is significantly inferior to the online version.
A number of functions are activated when connected to the Internet: text recognition, audio recognition, handwriting input. These features are experimental and under development - although, in fact, they are well implemented. On the one hand, in “field conditions” recognition is far from ideal. On the other hand, Google Translate is capable of translating simple and clear phrases. As a result, if the text or sound is not noisy, decoding is quite worthwhile.
Probably, the speech recognition function can be considered as a good tool for practicing pronunciation. It’s still too early to count on Google Translate as an assistant when having a “live” conversation with a foreigner. The role of translation, in the case of the functions described above, may fade into the background, but recognition results cannot be saved: export to Google Translate is not provided.
The phrasebook is another tool that deserves mention. It syncs with online devices linked to your Google account, allowing you to keep frequently used words with translations at your fingertips.
Resume. Google Translate would be correctly called a translator with dictionary functions available offline. Convenient and fast interface, wide choice language components, simple handling of dictionaries. The online recognition functions are also notable.
[+] Unique features
[+] Convenient and responsive interface
[+] Supports 80 languages
GoldenDict
Some dictionaries for Android provide only a shell, and in this case the actual dictionaries must be added independently. GoldenDict is just such a solution. On the one hand, it is inconvenient that you need to perform additional actions and waste time searching for dictionaries. Positive point- you can add only the specialized dictionaries you need. The shell is not only extremely easy to configure, but also versatile. Supported following types dictionaries: Lingvo, Babylon, MultiTran, StarDict, Lingoes and Dictd.
After adding to file system Dictionaries need to be indexed in order to include them in the search. Other dictionaries may be added installed programs; Typically, GoldenDict detects them and indexes them automatically. There can be an unlimited number of dictionaries, but the free version has a limit (5).
The search returns results fairly quickly and is case and punctuation insensitive. Separately, you can install morpheme dictionaries, then GoldenDict will take into account word forms.
If there are several dictionaries, the results are displayed in a list. There is a search by dictionary entry. Formatting allows you to highlight descriptions, terms, accented letters and, in general, make it easier to read. Voice acting is only available if the corresponding database is added (for example, from Lingvo). In the settings you can configure the output in detail and switch to night display mode.
What’s also useful is that GoldenDict can be integrated into reading programs, displaying the translation in a pop-up window, that is, acting as a contextual translator.
Resume. GoldenDict is an easy to configure and universal shell. It will be useful if detail (transcription, word forms, voice acting) and specialization in certain dictionaries. Or, say, in a situation where desktop dictionaries are used and you need to transfer them to mobile devices to access them offline.
[+] Translation details
[+] Taking into account morphology when searching
Fora Dictionary
Fora Dictionary is a cross-platform application available for both mobile (Android/iOS) and desktop (Windows/Mac/Linux) platforms. The desktop version is free, mobile versions contain advertising that is disabled when purchasing a license.
The main thing to note is the universal application of this shell. Similar to GoldenDict, there are no dictionaries by default. There are five ways to add dictionaries: packages, downloads, offline dictionaries on an SD card, online and Wikipedia. Not all methods are applicable to English-Russian translation, so copying local dictionaries and then pointing them to the program will be useful.
The following types of local dictionaries are supported: StarDict, XDXF, DSL, DICTD databases and simple dictionaries(TSV). Installation packages are installed from resources such as WordNet, FOLDOC, Factbook, Moby. Dictionary management has been implemented: they can not only be added from various sources, but also create profiles, group.
At the same time, the process of installing a Russian-language dictionary is not as simple as expected. Finding a free dictionary is not difficult, but its further connection is difficult due to the inconvenient interface, and indexing takes a long time.
Although it cannot be said that Fora Dictionary pleases with its modern design, the interface is flexible: article design, menu layout, panels and buttons. Navigation is also well thought out: hotkeys, abbreviations, sidebar, search and navigation history can be used.
The search supports fuzzy input, and hints are available as you type. The output can be formatted according to the Fora Dictionary settings, although it largely depends on the original layout of the dictionary.
Speech synthesis (TTS, or Text-to-Speech) is used for dubbing, available for English, French, German, Italian and Spanish languages. As an option, it is suggested to download an audio file high quality. In addition, voice input can be used when searching.
Resume. Fora Dictonary has common features with GoldenDict: based on the principle of adding dictionaries. True, in terms of the number of sources, none of the applications can compare with this application. similar decisions. Given Fora's cross-platform nature, the same databases can be used on mobile and desktop platforms.
[+] Support for many dictionary formats
[+] Convenient navigation and customizable interface
[−] Inconvenient adding of custom dictionaries
Bigg
Bigg - English-Russian dictionary and phrasebook. The application is convenient because the dictionaries are available offline without any preset, the need to download databases and other actions. All components occupy 50 MB and are copied to the SD card during installation. TO at this moment Bigg does not support external dictionaries or other translation directions. This is perhaps the only significant drawback when compared with competing solutions.
The dictionary includes Russian and English terms, more than 3 million in total. dictionary entries and about 2 thousand phrases in the phrasebook. On the one hand, this is relatively small, but there are also advantages: quick start of the application and instant search in the database. There is no need to switch the translation direction - the program does this automatically. The search is carried out taking into account morphology.
When translating, it is not necessary to open a dictionary entry: the search results already provide options. If multiple words are entered, the translation for each of them will be displayed. The article displays translation options grouped by parts of speech, and transcription is available. Through a separate section of the application you can familiarize yourself with irregular verbs.
The Bigg Phrasebook contains expressions in popular topics, general phrases - they are all carefully structured. Words and expressions from the phrasebook and dictionary can be added to favorites for quick access to them.
Resume. Bigg is one of the best English-Russian dictionaries. It will be useful to users learning the language. It is very easy to use and contains only the necessary functions, without requiring preliminary configuration. The only thing missing is the ability to add own dictionaries and support for languages other than English.
[+] Speed and ease of use
[+] Translation is available immediately after installation
[−] Inability to connect custom dictionaries
ColorDict
ColorDict provides for connecting dictionaries from Google Play and other online sources. They can be used offline in the future. Some network functions are used, for example, when searching for a word on Wikipedia.
As for offline dictionaries, there is support for the relatively popular StarDict format. You can copy the required set to the dictdata folder. Dictionaries are indexed automatically and are subsequently available for use. In the corresponding section of the application, you can sort dictionaries and assign color labels to them - convenient, say, for grouping.
Search works well when working with many dictionaries: options are displayed, you can view previously entered terms in the history, add items to your favorites, and set their sorting order. The result from any field is copied to the clipboard. As a wish, it would be nice to implement adding results to favorites and then exporting them.
When displaying terms, blocks are used various colors, reading is quite comfortable. There are three display options to choose from: WebView, TextView and TextView Space. Unfortunately, some dictionaries do not provide even minimal formatting, making the text difficult to read.
Language learners will find the TTS voiceover option useful, with American and British versions. Transcription is not available everywhere; this option depends on the original content of the dictionary.
From additional features- ColorDict integrates with reading programs, namely FBReader, Moon+ Reader, Cool Reader and ezPDF Reader. Thus, he can act as a context translator.
Resume. ColorDict works with local dictionaries and supports Wikipedia search. Another plus is integration with reading programs, which allows you to use ColorDict as a contextual translator (along with GoldenDict).
[+] Connecting StarDict dictionaries
[+] Integration with reading programs
[+] Color labels for blocks and dictionaries
"Offline dictionaries"
“Offline dictionaries,” as the name suggests, offer access to dictionaries without an Internet connection. However, to add them you still need to download the necessary databases. About 50 multilingual dictionaries are offered various directions: English, Russian, French, German, Chinese, Hebrew, etc. For Russian, at the time of review, 12 directions and dictionaries are available, for English - 32. Adding local dictionaries is not provided.
The program is not very user friendly. Even if we assume that advertising - as a distracting factor - can be turned off when purchasing a license, the translation adds confusion: “option, preferences” and other inscriptions distract from the essence.
Now about the search. Filters allow you to set search criteria. In theory, this could be useful for clarifying spelling (although in in this case fuzzy search would be more convenient). Filters are ideal for solving crossword puzzles, although this task cannot be called specialized for translation.
You can display the result either on a separate dictionary page or in a list. Another inconvenience is that “Offline dictionaries” do not use a single database, which significantly slows down the search, taking up time when switching between dictionaries. The same GoldenDict dictionary offers a convenient option - displaying all results in a single list.
The actual display of articles in the “Dictionaries” is well detailed, there is a grouping by parts of speech. Highlighting is not available and transcription is not provided. Available TTS synthesis (including British and American pronunciation, plus 6 additional languages), but it is also not very convenient, since the entire article is synthesized, and not the search word in the search line (see Fora Dictionary).
Resume. We can assume that the application copes with its main responsibilities, allowing you to quickly install the necessary dictionaries and get a comprehensive translation of a word. Negative factor The problem is that insufficient attention has been paid to the ergonomics of the application. This is especially noticeable when actively accessing dictionaries and searching for words.
Pivot table
Application | Google Translate | GoldenDict | Fora Dictionary | Bigg | ColorDict | Offline dictionaries |
Developer | Google Inc. | GoldenDict | NG-Computing | Alexey Ilyin | Notes | NGHS.fr |
Full version price | for free | $4,99 | for free | $2,99 | for free | $2,05 |
Android version | depends on device | depends on device | 1.0+ | depends on device | depends on device | depends on device |
Supported languages | 80 | unlimited | unlimited | Russian, English | unlimited | unlimited |
Adding online dictionaries | + | − | + | − | + | + |
Adding local dictionaries | − | Lingvo, Babylon, MultiTran, StarDict, Lingoes, Dictd | StarDict, XDXF, DSL, DICTD, TSV | − | StarDict | − |
Voice acting | + | + | + | − | + | + |
Contextual translation (integration with reading programs) | − | + | − | − | FBReader, Moon+ Reader, Cool Reader, ezPDF Reader | − |
Other options | Phrasebook; recognition of audio, photos, manuscripts; translation of phrases, SMS | − | Search on Wikipedia | Phrasebook |